Going back to the original languages of Scripture is essential for understanding the Bible, but it isn’t always done responsibly. Just because you are referencing Greek and Hebrew doesn’t make you right.
In this article, we will break down some commonly repeated myths about the biblical languages.
01 Myth
There are secret messages encoded in Hebrew letters
Hebrew letters were originally Egyptian hieroglyphs that had certain meanings...but so were English letters! Both the letter “B” and the letter “ב” stand for the “b” sound. God did not bury His Word in code form for us to decipher.
Did you know? The English letter B was originally an Egyptian hieroglyph that meant house!
This is what the progression looked like:
“house”
“bet”
All true alphabets (which, by definition, connect a sound and a symbol) are derived from the same source: a Semitic group in the Sinai desert. (The Hebrews were also a Semitic group, but we do not know the precise relationship between the alphabet-inventors and the Hebrews.)
This group did something that would forever change the world. They took Egyptian hieroglyphics and started to associate a symbol with a sound rather than a symbol with a word.
Before that point, all languages were composed of symbols representing words instead of sounds. What this group did was take the first sound of the word represented by a hieroglyph and make that the sound of the symbol.
For example, the word for “house” was “beit” in that Semitic group’s language. So if they wanted to use the Egyptian symbols for their language, they would say “beit” when they saw the following hieroglyph for “house”:
“house”
Under the new system, the Semitic group would say “b” for the Egyptian hieroglyph instead of “beit,” allowing them to spell any of their words with a limited set of symbols.
This was the beginning of the alphabet, and it revolutionized communication. It opened up the possibility for all languages to use the same basic system of writing, and indeed, that is precisely what happened.
This brings us to a major myth about the Hebrew language, and specifically the pre-biblical version of it often referred to as paleo-Hebrew.
Some have claimed that every paleo-Hebrew letter has a special meaning corresponding to a word. There are supposedly hidden meanings in Scripture that come from the meaning of the original words associated with the symbols. God’s name, Yahweh, (written with the consonants YHWH) supposedly means the following:
The claim
| Y | behold |
| H | hand |
| W | nail |
| H | hand |
From this, they deduce that God’s name is a hidden reference to the Cross.
The first problem with this is that Y should mean “hand”, H should mean “window” and W should mean “hook”. In other words, this claim is factually incorrect!
The claim
| Y | behold |
| H | hand |
| W | nail |
| H | hand |
The Actual
| Y | hand |
| H | window |
| W | hook |
| H | window |
The second problem is that this isn’t how Hebrew works. As cool as it might seem to decipher hidden meanings in the Bible, God communicated in a way that anyone could understand — using normal human language.
Hebrew letters were originally Egyptian hieroglyphs that had certain meanings...but so were English letters! The forms of the letters took on different shapes, but the new “meaning” developed by the alphabet-inventors continues to hold across languages. Both the letter “B” and the letter “ב” stand for the “b” sound. Here’s what the Hebrew progression looked like:
“house”
“bet”
bet
When you see the letter “b” you don’t think of a “house” — even though that’s what it originally meant in Egyptian. It’s the same with Hebrew. Even though the letter “ב” came from a symbol that meant “house,” it no longer meant that once the alphabet revolution happened.
That’s why it’s not correct to attribute special meanings to the letters of the paleo-Hebrew alphabet. The language was written out with alphabetic letters just like ours — not hieroglyphs that stood for a full word.
God did not bury His Word in code form for us to decipher. He chose to communicate through a regular human language — understandable to any who would read it.
02 Myth
The past perfective tense signals a “once for all completed action”
Verb forms like “have” + -en and -ed have meanings that are far more complex than these kinds of simple descriptions — and often, the simple descriptions are just flat-out wrong. Don’t read too much into the “tenses” and understand that the precise meaning of the tenses is more complicated than you probably think.
- “A past action with continuing relevance”
- “A once for all completed action”
All too often I hear pastors and teachers repeat these types of phrases when expositing Scripture. They are describing the supposed meanings contained in verb tenses. But it’s a lot more complicated than it might seem.
Let’s think about English verbs first. Verb forms like have + -en and -ed have meanings that are far more complex than these kinds of simple descriptions — and often, the simple descriptions are just flat-out wrong. Consider a simple discourse like the following:
A
My two-year-old son is a mess. He has broken this vase. He has smashed our TV. He has even taken a golf club to our car.
B
My two-year-old son is a mess. He broke this vase. He smashed our TV. He even took a golf club to our car.
In these two short paragraphs, my two-year-old son is described as a mess. The sentences afterwards give examples of how he has wrecked things. The verbs broke, smash, and take are used, but the forms in A use the have + -en forms of the verbs, and the forms in B use the -ed forms of the verbs (which only sometimes actually have -ed).
Here’s the point with this example: there is no appreciable difference between the meanings of A and B in this case. There is sometimes a significant difference between these verb forms, but there are a number of factors that govern the meaning of the forms, and pastors and teachers (and even many Greek grammarians!) often do not understand all that goes into the meaning of the verb forms.
To illustrate, here is what G.K. Beale says about a verb form in Revelation 5:7 in his commentary on the Greek text (1999:357):
“The perfect tense εἴληφεν (“he took”) functions as an aorist.”
G.K. Beale, Commentary on Revelation 5:7
In Revelation 5:7, a perfect form (usually equivalent to have + -en in English) is translated as a simple past tense (the “aorist” normally equals the -ed form, or the normal past tense). In other words, there seems to be overlap between the perfect and past tense, similar to how we saw the two forms overlap in meaning in the above example.
Many, many more examples could be multiplied where the verb forms do not necessarily mean what we might expect them to mean (or at least, the verb forms do not jive with some current theories about what they should mean).
The moral of the story: don’t read too much into the “tenses” and understand that the precise meaning of the tenses is more complicated than you probably think.
If you really want a deep-dive on how to understand the verb forms, check out these resources on the topic.
03 Myth
You can derive a word’s meaning from its etymology
Words with the same root are normally similar in meaning, but they often differ in important ways. The relationship between these words is complex, and we cannot necessarily derive one meaning from the other. When Paul speaks of the Gospel being the δύναμις (related to English “dynamite”) of God for salvation, we are not to think of explosions.
All languages make use of roots.
For example, the word examine is composed of a root √exam + a suffix -ine. We can attach this suffix to other roots to form other words, such as √image to make imagine.
You can see how the meanings of the complex words examine and imagine are related to their roots. In some sense, to examine something is to conduct an exam, and to imagine something is to conjure up an image in your mind. So far so good.
The problem is that words with the same root are normally similar in meaning, but they often differ in important ways. The Hebrew root √ראש forms the words ראש “head”, ראשון “first”, and ראשית “beginning/best.” Again, you can see how these words are related, but they do not mean the same thing.
When ראש “head” is used, we think of a body part...
...but when ראשית “beginning” is used, we should not think of a body part.
The trouble comes when you begin to associate a root with a particular word formed from that root (as if √ראש meant ראש “head”). The word ראשית “beginning” comes from the root √ראש, which does not mean “head” but means something abstract like the top or beginning of something, whether it be a person (i.e. “head”), time (i.e. “beginning”), or place (i.e. “first”).
Similarly, we do not think of the body part “head” in statements like:
- Bob is way ahead of Sue.
- Mark has been making headway on his project.
- The heading of this section seems misleading.
Here’s the point: the relationship between these words is complex, and we cannot necessarily derive one meaning from the other. Other roots work in different ways and have different relationships between the words that they make. It is too easy to say too much when speaking of “root meanings.”
Another problem is that words across languages may share a root, but they may differ in meaning substantially. Here’s a common example:
- δύναμιςThe Greek word δύναμις “power”
- dynamiteThe English word “dynamite,” which borrows the root of the original Greek word
One can see that the two words are related. Dynamite is certainly an impressive display of power. However, that does not mean that the Greek word δύναμις has the same meaning as the English word dynamite. Dynamite explodes, power does not — it is just an abstract concept. When Paul speaks of the Gospel being the δύναμις of God for salvation, we are not to think of explosions.
Root meanings are not wholly irrelevant when doing exegesis, but more often than not, they are presented in misleading and unhelpful ways.
04 Myth
The “literal” meaning is always the right one
The phrase, “running water,” does not mean “the physical act of running plus H2O.” We don’t interpret the word “running” literally in this context. The same can be said of the Hebrew equivalent of “running water,” which is מים חיים “living water.” This Hebrew phrase refers to flowing water, just like the phrase “running water” in English. It is unhelpful to say that מים חיים literally means “living water,” as if some sort of special water is being referred to.
Related to the root meaning fallacy is the literal meaning fallacy.
In this error, words are decomposed into parts and a so-called “literal meaning” of each word is given that is supposed to be more accurate or true to the original meaning.
The English example running water illustrates this well. Does the phrase mean:
No. It is simply wrong to say that we interpret running “literally” in the phrase running water.
The same can, in fact, be said of the Hebrew equivalent of running water, which is not מים רצים “running water” but מים חיים “living water.”
When referring to flowing water, Hebrew uses the metaphor of “living” rather than “running.” In this case again, it would be wrong to understand “living water” to mean:
Does this mean Ancient Hebrew speakers understood flowing water differently than modern English speakers because we use the metaphor of “running” and they used the metaphor of “living”? Probably not.
In Hebrew, it is unhelpful to say that there is a literal meaning of מים חיים that means “living water”, as if some sort of special water is being referred to. The phrase refers to flowing water, just like running water in English. (The same is also probably true of the metaphor for “flowing water” found in John 4 when Jesus is speaking to the woman at the well, though that story presents other complexities.)
05 Myth
The biblical languages are “special” and should be treated differently than other languages
Greek and Hebrew are real languages that real humans used to communicate real messages. God used the ordinary means of Greek and Hebrew to communicate extraordinary things. Treat Biblical Greek and Hebrew like real languages so that you can understand the Bible in the way that God originally intended for humans to understand it.
Greek and Hebrew are real languages that real humans used to communicate real messages.
Some of the things they communicated were ordinary and mundane. Other messages were extraordinary, particularly those communicated by God to humans. However, God used the ordinary means of Greek and Hebrew to communicate extraordinary things, so if you want to understand His act of communication, you need to learn to understand Greek and Hebrew as real languages.
As you have been reading this article, you have not been over-analyzing all the tenses or trying to figure out how the root of a word like communicate is related to other words. Nor have you thought of the “literal meaning” of understand, and you have certainly not been thinking of the word “house” every time you have seen the letter “b.” As an English speaker, you have been reading through the text to understand the message I am communicating.
That is exactly what you should do with the biblical text. That does not mean there is no room for close readings of the text. Indeed, we should read the Bible, or any important text, carefully, but we should still treat it as a text.
This is exactly our goal in Biblingo. We treat Biblical Greek and Hebrew like real languages, so that you can understand the Bible in the way that God originally intended for humans to understand it. Learning any language takes practice and work, but God’s extraordinary message is worth the effort.
